Skip to content
Claims and Decisions

Repair or Replace After a Storm: How to Decide

Key takeaways

  • Age, how much of the roof is damaged and the roof's material all matter.
  • Matching and brittleness can make repair harder on older roofs.
  • A written scope and photos make the decision clearer.

How old is the roof?

A young roof with isolated damage is usually a good candidate for repair. A roof near the end of its life may not hold a repair well, and you may be paying twice.

How much is damaged?

Damage on one slope can be repaired or the slope can be replaced. Widespread hail bruising or wind damage across many slopes often points to replacement.

Will new shingles match?

Older shingles weather and some are discontinued, so a repair may show. We tell you what to expect and show samples.

Is the roof still repairable?

Brittle shingles can crack when they are lifted for repair. A roofer can test a few and tell you honestly.

What does your policy say?

Some policies cover repair, some cover replacement and some pay depreciated value. Ask your insurance company about your policy.

Get it in writing

Ask for a written scope with photos for both options so you can compare them calmly.

Related services

Questions about your own roof? Call or text (800) 207-0499, or use the form below.

Roof damaged?

Tell us what happened.

Give us your address, what the storm did and how to reach you. We read every message and reply with clear next steps and a crew when it is safe to work. In an emergency, call or text instead.

  • Your address or city, what you see and whether water is coming in. Photos from the ground are plenty, and a perfect description is never required
  • Anything you saved from a Storm Kit tool, so we do not ask you twice
  • Emergency cover first, then dated photos, a written scope and a clear price before the permanent repair, and a clean property when we leave
Water coming in? Call or text, any hour(800) 207-0499

Your roofing request

Prefer to type? Text your request. We only use your details to respond to your request.